The US Supreme Court yesterday declined to hear a case brought by a right wing legal group on behalf of two students at a suburban Seattle-area high school who sued after the school refused to let them set up a group that would have accepted only openly declared Christians as voting members.
A appeals court said the school’s student council was justified in denying a charter to the proposed group that would have been open only to students who signed a “statement of faith”. Because the high court will not hear the case, the appellate ruling stands.
The case started in September, 2001 when Sarice Undis, then a junior at Kentridge High School in Kent, Wash., and Julianne Stewart, then a sophomore, asked school's student council to charter a group a student group called “Truth Bible Club”. Truth members, who originally could be students of any faith, would read a Bible verse over the school's intercom system once a week and decorate the school once a month, Seattle Times reports.
After a ruling in a separate Washington court case said that schools could recognize faith-based student groups, Undis and Stewart applied for formal recognition of their group which, according to its proposed charter, would have required voting members to sign sign a “statement of faith” accepting Jesus Christ as their “personal savior” and the Bible as “the only infallible, authoritative Word of God”, according to the Times.
That charter was unanimously denied by the student council – the Associated Student Body, or ASB, which said the membership rule was discriminatory, KPLU reports.
“This group wanted to receive public funds, wanted to be an ASB club. To be an ASB club, your membership must be open to all students,” said Kent Schools general counsel Chuck Lind.
Backed by the conservative Alliance Defense Fund (ADF), Undis and Stewart sued the school district, but lost in both the trial court and in a subsequent appeal.
More...