February 2. 2010

image The reenactment of the first-day opening statements in the Prop 8 is now available in two parts at YouTube.

Ted Olson’s opening statement begins at 15:08 in the hour-plus clip below. Judge Vaughn Walker interrupted Olson several times to ask several perhaps-significant questions during the statement. The defendants’ opening statement by Charles Cooper—also interrupted repeatedly by Walker—begins at the start of Chapter 2.

(All videos, are posted to this YouTube channel and at MarriageTrial.com, which also offers explanatory commentary about the trial.)

But before getting to the opening statements Walker put himself on record about the proposed webcast of the proceedings—an issue that was still under consideration by the high court in DC.

At the start of the first chapter, Walker defends his decision to allow webcast of the trial video. That decision was, of course, overruled a few days later by a split decision of the US Supreme Court.

“The issue of the public’s right to access the court’s proceedings is an important one,” Walker says. “I think it’s highly unfortunate that the judicial conference and the courts have not dealt with the issue in the past and have not in a considered and careful manner worked through the issues.” He compliments the attorneys before him for briefs on the issue which he calls “very helpful, indeed.”

Of course, the conservative majority on the Supreme Court didn’t agree that the public has a “right to access the court’s proceedings”. And so, we’re left with these impressive—albeit slow-to-surface—reenactments produced by John Ireland and John Ainsworth and performed by a group of volunteer actors.

Top military leaders call for one-year study of DADT repeal

Posted by NewsEditor  at 1:25 PM (PT)
In: dadt, politics, video

image The nation’s top two military officials told a Senate hearing this morning that they support repeal of the military’s ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ policy, but said they’ll need another year of study before they could recommend ways to implement a repeal.

“No matter how I look at the issue, I cannot escape being troubled by the fact that we have in place a policy which forces young men and women to lie about who they are in order to defend their fellow citizens,” Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told the Senate Armed Services Committee, New York Times reports.

[see video clip of hearing statements at end of post]

He stressed, however, that in endorsing a repeal of the policy he was “speaking for myself and myself only”, Washington Post reports.

Secretary of Defense Robert Gates told the committee in his opening statement, “I fully support the president's decision. The question before us is not whether the military prepares to make this change, but how we best prepare for it. We’ve received our orders from the commander in chief and are moving out accordingly.”

But he told the committee, “If legislation is passed repealing ‘don't ask don't tell', we would feel it very important that we be given some period of time for that implementation, at least a year," Reuters reports.

In his prepared remarks, Mullen said, “The chiefs and I are in complete agreement with the approach that Sec. Gates has outlined. We believe that any implementation plan for a policy permitting gays and lesbians to serve openly in the armed forces must be carefully derived, sufficiently thorough, and thoughtfully executed.”

In a statement issued after the hearing, Aubrey Sarvis, executive director of Servicemembers Legal Defense Network (SLDN), a DADT-repeal advocacy group, applauded Gates and especially Mullen for their statements to the committee, saying they have “laid out a roadmap for full repeal” of DADT.

But Sarvis said a one-year study period is “too long and unnecessary”. He said the process of repeal “must have finality”. He recommended that Congress immediately act on repeal legislation rather than waiting for another year.

More...

image Should President Obama attend the National Prayer Breakfast that’s scheduled for March?

Rachel Maddow discussed the question yesterday with her guest, Melanie Sloan, the executive director of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW). [see video clip after the break]

Every president since Eisenhower has attended the annual political-religious event. The White House yesterday told TRMS that President Obama will attend this year’s event. But this year’s prayer breakfast presents unique challenges for the president or other politicians who attend the event.

That’s because the group that sponsors the event is tied in a number of ways to the Ugandan politicians who have most strongly supported his country’s ‘kill-gays’ bill, a proposed law that would impose draconian penalties—possibly including death in some cases—for the “crime” of being gay.

More...

image Cheers erupt for San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus Saturday night from part of the capacity crowd at Redding’s Cascade Theatre San Francisco Chronicle photo by Lacy Adams

San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus performed this weekend to capacity crowds in both Redding and Chico, California. Redding. Chico.

Those are two small cities at the northern tip of California’s Central Valley. And they’re deeply conservative strongholds. Like most of their Central Valley neighbors to the south, voters in Redding and Chico strongly favored Proposition 8 in 2008. Seventy percent of voters in Shasta County, which includes Redding, voted for Prop. 8. In Butte County, where Chico is located, 56.7 percent of voters favored the measure.

And that’s why the San Francisco chorus was there.

San Francisco Chronicle columnist CW Nevius explains:

Make no mistake, this isn’t a tour. It’s a groundbreaking political action. In the upcoming months, they’ll visit Bakersfield, Fresno, and Tracy, all strongholds for Prop. 8, the measure that banned same-sex marriage. They hope their music will help personalize the fight for gays to marry.

It is more than a small gamble. They could face protests, fights or even worse - complete indifference.

But none of those things happened on the first two stops on what the chorus calls its Freedom Tour. Instead the chorus met its full tour attendance goals during the first two stops, Chico Enterprise Record reports:

More...

Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand vowed on yesterday's The Rachel Maddow Show to do everything she can in the Congress to repeal the military’s ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ policy sooner rather than later.

“I do think now is the time to act. And I think Congress can take its own action and repeal the policy and during that time, the President can issue a stop-loss or issue a moratorium.”

She said that it’s important to stop the policy as quickly as possible for the sake of military readiness.